Diatom Filter? System 1 vs Vortex?

i was wondering this also about getting a diatom filter but have no experience with them.

I have the Vortex XL - thanks to this website! It's the best diatom filter out, but it can be slightly cumbersome to set-up. Once you set it up a few times it's no problem at all. The Vortex D-1 is for smaller aquariums.
I highly recommend this product! I use it after each water change (once a week). The water is crystal clear..

Ok...

even more beginner question here.

How does a diatom filter work with the powder and all as opposed to water polishing with say a HOT Magnum and its' 1 micron filter?

In the vortex diatom filters the powder coats the filter bag. Water is then forced through powder making for very fine filtration.

Can't you also do the same thing with a Magnum? Mine came with diatom powder years ago when I got it. Just wondering because a HOT Magnum is like $50 and the Vortex is almost $100. The magnum would also be more versatile. But, probably just as cumbersome as the vortex to set up.

Just my two cents.

p.s. why do want a diatom? My water is as crystal clear as I've seen and I have foam and biomedia in my filters. If make a big mess I hook up the Mag with the micron and it clears up in a couple hours.

Originally posted by DIYMatt
Can't you also do the same thing with a Magnum?

Click to expand...

Some like their Magnums, others have said they don't filter as good as the Vortex. The Vortex is designed strictly as a Diatom Filter. The Vortex XL is rather large, and I suppose this helps with its effectiveness. It takes 3 cups of diatom powder for each use.
For smaller aquariums, there's the Vortex D-1.

Will a diatom filter clear out the haze in the water that is the result of moving plants in a clay substrate?

Originally posted by Matak
Will a diatom filter clear out the haze in the water that is the result of moving plants in a clay substrate?

Click to expand...

Absolutely! It's great for that!

thata what havin a diatom filter is basically used for, taking out all the tiny particles!

anybody use the system 1 filter?