NY Pizza Suprema

We loved it. Quick service, great choice. Plenty of tables and a nice vibe. Pizzas were out of this world. Incredible crusts and just the right amount of toppings and a perfect temperature.

Food was excellent and service was fast! Very efficient team. Great stop near Madison Square Garden!

I was amazed to find such great pizza right by Penn Station! I was really just looking for a quick slice and had no expectations that this was going to be such good pizza. It's a pretty quick spot, with your usual counter service, but they do have some tables as well. In this case, I was in a bit of a rush, so I just took my slice to know.

If you're a fan of pepperoni, you should go for it! They throw a ton of meat onto the slice and the pepperoni curls up in just the right way. I'm usually more of a triangle over a square slice fan, but in this case, the square hit the spot. Highly recommend for pizza fans!

If you're craving authentic New York pizza, NY Pizza Suprema is the place to be. Despite always being crowded, their fast-moving service ensures you won't be waiting long to indulge in their delicious offerings. From mouthwatering pizzas to satisfying sandwiches, MY Pizza has something for everyone.

I must admit, NY Pizza S serves some of the best pizza in New York City. The flavors are rich, the crust is perfectly crispy, and the toppings are always fresh. However, I can't ignore the fact that the service can sometimes be lacking. While the food deserves a solid five stars, the service occasionally falls short, earning it a three-star rating in my book. Nevertheless, this minor inconvenience doesn't overshadow the exceptional quality of their food.

What sets NY Pizza S apart is their dedication to customer comfort. Despite the bustling atmosphere, they offer ample seating and even a convenient restroom--an absolute rarity in the busy streets of New York City.

The ultimate seal of approval for NY Pizza S comes from my two favorite food critics, who also swear by its authenticity and flavor. If that's not a testament to this place's legitimacy, I don't know what is.

In conclusion, while the service may not always be top-notch, the outstanding food and convenient amenities make MY Pizza a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast in New York City.

Arrived in New York and ran straight to grab a slice. I always appreciate the meat lovers but to compare this pizza against all those around the midtown/manhattan I would recommend the simple cheese pizza. You will find out the difference between this place and any of those corner pizza joints. Cheese distribution and amount. The crisp under the dough and the not too tangy but flavorful pizza sauce.

Still considered one of my favorites over many years!

Above average NY style pizza from a restaurant that has been around for decades. I tried the "suprema" (aka the supreme - sausage, bell pepper, pepperoni, etc).

Stopped in for dinner at 5pm and found plenty of seating. It was clean and simple, but no complaints. Quick and friendly service. Got the burrata, hot honey, and chicken parm. Hot honey reigned supreme. Only bummer was when we arrived they were out of bbq chicken, but it was replenished when we left. Will have to try that one another time! Slices were huge and had a great crusty crunch of the crust. Highly recommend.

One of the best pizza joints in town, we had been to a few the last few times we have been in the city. This one has a lot of different kinds of toppings.., the best... the Sicilian!!!! I love white pizza and this was a white pizza with garlic but this took the cake. They are fresh when you get there and they do a quick heat to give them that final crunch. We went when they first opened so we got the best! Definitely going back again.

Looking for huge slices of delicious pizza. This is the place to start. Tried three different slices, they were all amazing. Crust was nice and crispy. The restaurant was basic, but well kept. The food was ready quickly and everyone was friendly.

If you are looking for a quick slice of good NY pizza this is your place located conveniently right by Penn Station. This corner pizzeria gives quick excellent service and delicious pizza. So many varieties to choose from and all were fantastic. You will be in and out quickly and the price for New York is right.